German Border Troops

German Border Troops
Did the loss in a storm of a Mulberry Harbour during the Normandy invasion lengthen WW2 in Europe?

I recently asked a question about whether the Second World War in Europe could have been won in 1944. Answers suggested that this was prevented by problems in supplying the troops as they advanced on Germany.

When they landed in Normandy in June 1944, the Allies set up two articificial Mulberry Harbours. However, one was lost in a storm ten days later. Did this lengthen the war?

There are at least two issues here:-
1. Did the loss of a Mulberry Harbour delay the breakout from the Normandy beach head?
2. Would the second Mulberry Harbour have enabled enough additional suppies to be landed to have enabled the advance across France in August 1944 to continue to the German border and beyond?

No, the loss of the Harbour didn’t really delay the war that much as once the Allies made a bridgehead their first objective was to take and hold nearby ports so they wouldn’t have to rely on the MUlberry harbours. The Mulberry harbours were really only a small stepping stone, they were needed to get supplies and heavy armour across so that then we could move into Fracne and take ports so we could get a proper supply line.
Moreover, I doubt the loss of one Mulberry harbour really meant that the war was slowed down by much, the lack of supplies didn’t last long and the Allies managed to transfer more supplies on to the remaining harbour. What did slow the Allies down were things like the the town of Caen which took the Allies much longer to take than they expected because the Germans held it so while, also things like the brilliant German Tiger Tank which all the Allied Tank crew feared, and also the failure of Operation Market Garden in Holland and failed crossings of the Rhine River.

German troops cross the Polish border

eBay Logo  

FRANCE ~ 1915 FRENCH TROOPS TRANSPORTING ARMY AIRPLANES TO GERMAN BORDER


FRANCE ~ 1915 FRENCH TROOPS TRANSPORTING ARMY AIRPLANES TO GERMAN BORDER


$9.99


German WWII Swiss Border Storm Troops 168.BAT  1939


German WWII Swiss Border Storm Troops 168.BAT 1939


$1.99


German WWII Swiss Border Storm Troops 48.BAT  1940


German WWII Swiss Border Storm Troops 48.BAT 1940


$1.99


East German Germany Collar Tab Boards Border Frontier Guard Troop NVA Volksarmee


East German Germany Collar Tab Boards Border Frontier Guard Troop NVA Volksarmee


$5.99


East German Germany Shoulder Boards Border Frontier Guard Troop NVA Volksarmee


East German Germany Shoulder Boards Border Frontier Guard Troop NVA Volksarmee


$4.99


DDR EAST GERMAN ARMY OFFICER


DDR EAST GERMAN ARMY OFFICER “Border Troops Collar Badges” PAIR NEW GRENZTRUPPEN


$11.85


DDR NVA EAST GERMAN CUFF TITLE BORDER TROOPS


DDR NVA EAST GERMAN CUFF TITLE BORDER TROOPS “GRENZTRUPPEN” NEW


$13.04


1961 EAST GERMAN NATIONAL BORDER TROOPS ARMY MEDAL


1961 EAST GERMAN NATIONAL BORDER TROOPS ARMY MEDAL


$98.00


1961 East German Water Thrower Aimed at U.S. Troops on Berlin Border Press Photo


1961 East German Water Thrower Aimed at U.S. Troops on Berlin Border Press Photo


$9.99


1961 British troops patrol along East German  border. O


1961 British troops patrol along East German border. O


$18.88


1914 Allied & Axis Troops at Barricade on Swiss-German Border Orig Press Photo


1914 Allied & Axis Troops at Barricade on Swiss-German Border Orig Press Photo


$13.99


PAIR EAST GERMAN BORDER TROOPS ENLISTED SHOULDER BOARDS


PAIR EAST GERMAN BORDER TROOPS ENLISTED SHOULDER BOARDS


$9.95


COLD WAR DDR EAST GERMAN BORDER TROOPS PIONEER PATCH


COLD WAR DDR EAST GERMAN BORDER TROOPS PIONEER PATCH


$4.95


[backlinksmage]

Comments are closed.